Commie FFF Kaylith-Oni
Flickable (Click between screenshots to drag!):
| Commie | FFF | Kaylith-Oni |
|---|---|---|
| Filename: [Commie] Red Data Girl – 01 [043C47ED].mkv File size: 405 MB Format: Hi10P Translation: Original Japanese: No honorifics English: American English OP/ED Lyrics: Simple softsubbed Encoding: Pastebin Chaptered: Yes Speed: Fast | Filename: [FFF] Red Data Girl – 01 [EA5BADED].mkv File size: 430 MB Format: Hi10P Translation: Original Japanese: Honorifics English: American English OP/ED Lyrics: Simple softsubbed Encoding: Pastebin Chaptered: Yes Speed: Varies | Filename: [Kaylith-Oni]_Red_Data_Girl_-_01_[720p][F981E9B3].mkv File size: 353 MB Format: Hi10P Translation: Original Japanese: Honorifics English: American English OP/ED Lyrics: Complex softsubbed Encoding: Pastebin Chaptered: Yes Speed: Varies |
| 
| 
|
Which group are you watching?
Red Data Girl
Feel free to leave comments below, either about the groups' releases, or if I have made an error anywhere, or if you would like to request your group to be added to the list.
I automatically list groups who post their releases on Tokyo-Tosho. If you don't post on there, it is unlikely I will find it.
Saturday 6th April 2013 
6:22 PM 
Holo
I watch Zero-Raws.
Can I suggest putting the screenshots in the order they appear in the video?
Done.
One group per vertical selection is the best format.
Horizontal comparison and flickable() on [Default]
Vertical comparisons are hard on the eyes.
I’m still used to horizontal, but I can see how vertical would look great with a tablet. flickable() is a great idea and makes me wonder why such a thing wasn’t used before.
I would recomend adding links or information such that as the AniDB or ANN Page for the series, also have a comparison of release dates.
I’ve given an indication of the speed. Is that what you mean?
I like this view best, but the images need to be table bound so that when they load asynchronously, the images to be compared load beside the area where it’s match will load.
Due to the way my folder parsing script works, it’s kinda hard to do that, lol. It’s only a minor annoyance, I guess.
Also, At the top should be a list of items which can be compared, by group, from which you can select two, and that would bring the two versions up side by side, this could be accomplished by using hidden elements… checkboxes would make a good default interface control, but that way you can bring up axb or axc or axd or bxc or bxd or cxd etcetera.
LOL nevermind…
This is great stuff! Also, this is the type of view I prefer. Horizontal with flickable on.
I see FFF having a typo in their typesetting. Oh, well. I like them for their fast releases anyways. So, my vote would obviously go for them.
As for comment on the site, I think horizontal comparison is better.
The summary for Kaylith-Oni seems to be incorrect; they do have honorifics, at least in the screenshots.
Fixed
Perhaps you could make the bottom scroll at the bottom of the webpage and not where it is so you can scroll left to right and up and down more easily? Or am I missing something?
>make own subcomparison site
>this shit comes
>by fucking Doki
Welp, GG me.
i think horizontal with flickable is best. found the vertical a bit confusing to the eyes.
and vertical with flickable has one other minor problem. when you click and drag to scroll sideways; if you clicked on the picture, the picture gets enlarged. so you would need to avoid clicking the picture while scrolling. i dont know how it works with touch screen, but it doesnt work well with mouse.
I really like horizontal and don’t like vertical much at all. Vertical is too hard to scroll through.
I find that having to scroll down just to move the screen over is rather annoying. Is there any way to fix that or will it have to be done that way?
You can click in the screenshot area and drag your mouse. Just avoid the screenshot otherwise the lightbox will pop up.
Ah if that’s the case, the horizontal one is much better imo.
I think the overwhelming majority wants horizontal (default) so I’m just developing that atm.
I guess I’ll vote for Vertical comparison and flickable() on mode. Because in my browser the horizontal still extended too much, and i can’t even see more than one full pic. I can’t compare those images like that!
The vertical allows me to compare pics by 3 fansubs in one screen, so it’s WAY easier to look.
Anyway, thank you for doing this! I really appreciate you guys! Hope you can continue to post more comparison here ^^
Horizontal with flickable on, definitely. I like the poll idea. Hope it last.
The default horizontal layout looks great. Easy to view this way. I didn’t notice much change wish flickable() on or off, scrolling the screens is easy enough in both situations but I honestly don’t like the vertical layout that much.
Looks great and I prefer the horizontal scroll than vertical. Only thing I could say is to keep the file details fixed at the top of the page so you don’t have to scroll back up to see it.
Definitely horizontal with flickable on, but as stated before, the images can cause a little frustration.
This looks great but it’s a bit hard to scroll horizontally.
This view is good, but I found an issue with clickable: it doesn’t work with fullscreen mode (F11) – so if you used it in normal window and then switched to fullscreen, images might be stuck outside of window. Don’t know enough scripting or w/e it was written in to debug the problem, but still 🙂
Another thing – while this seems better than vertical, the lack of a horizontal scroll bar (unless it’s the last row) is annoying. Yes, that’s where clickable comes in, but it’s not that intuitive yet. Is there a way to provide a floating scroll bar? i.e. one that stays in a fixed position, much like a fixed background picture.
Another thing – maybe if you explain to “click between the screenshots” instead of “click on the white area”, it would be better understood… I’ve tried using it several times without success until I found what area you need to click and what it does ^_^
It is very useful and I really love the horizontal comparison with vertical scrolling.
In my opinion, the biggest issue with the vertical comparison is that you need to click somewhere inside that area so that you can scroll with the arrows. Otherwise you need to use the mouse to drag the bar, which I believe nobody does or at least would like to do. Probably using the wheel to scroll within that section could be a fair enough workaround but I still prefer the horizontal comparison and flickable on option.
One little note, the horizontal scroll bar is visible even when there is nothing to scroll. I think there is an “overflow-x” where is shouldn’t be.
I am using Chrome on Linux.
Holo, I just wanna say thank you for this great site!
nice work, thanks
Nice job!
I preffer the flickable horizontal comparison, it’s waaay better than the vertical one.
Just one thing. The screenshots from Kaylith-Oni are chopped (at least here). I have to go waaaay down to roll that thingy or uncheck Commie/FFF to I’ll be able to see them. Is there no way to fix this? I’m using Chrome, if that’ll help something.
Can’t you click between the screenshots and drag left?
Ohhh yes I can. Very nice
This is a great idea, as long as you include ALL subbed anime from a season, and not just the comparisons for the series that Doki are doing.
Horizontal mode, just the same as ji-hi and subcompare is definitely better. I can get 3 groups pics on screen at the same time that way, with vertical I can only get 2.
Don’t care one way or other for flickable.
I hope you are going to include the option to enable/disable groups in the chart like both ji-hi and subcompare had? This made it much easier to slowly eliminate groups while comparing until I got down to just the best ones to make a pick from.
Sorry, ignore tha last paragraph in my previous comment, I just saw it at the top of the screen. Thanks!
Guys what’s ur opinion on subs lol (I know site setup is important but talk about subs too :P)
Kaylith-Oni is nice, but the karaoke is CPU intense and causes lag on my computers, kinda like what happened with UTWoots’ Sword Art Online. FFF should be better in that regard, I’m guessing.
MPC with xy-vsfilter should fix the lag.
Not a fan of the flickable thing. On my 32 in monitor @ 1920×1080 I can’t ‘flick’ it so that the 3 columns are centered. It’s either way off to the left cutting part of the left column off or way off to the right cutting the right column off. Would be better if The flicking would rest on the center of the selected groups.
Also, it doesn’t seem that you can reenable flicking by the enable button after disabling it.
Refreshing does help if there are errors.